Scroll to top
© 2020, Norebro theme by Colabrio, All right reserved.

Balancing Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations

by Dara

In today’s hyper-competitive business landscape, companies are constantly seeking innovative ways to engage and retain customers. One such strategy that has gained significant traction is gamification. Gamification involves the integration of game elements and mechanics into non-gaming contexts to motivate and engage users or customers. While gamification holds immense potential, the key to its success lies in understanding and harnessing the power of motivation.

Motivation is the driving force behind human behavior, and it plays a pivotal role in the effectiveness of gamification in business. In this blog post, we will delve into the intricacies of motivation, specifically focusing on the interplay between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in gamification. 

Understanding Intrinsic Motivation

Intrinsic motivation refers to the internal desire or drive that compels individuals to engage in an activity for its own sake, deriving satisfaction and enjoyment from the process. In the context of business, intrinsic motivation is a powerful tool for fostering long-term engagement and loyalty.

Consider a fitness app like Strava that encourages users to track their daily workouts. The sheer satisfaction of achieving personal fitness goals can serve as an intrinsic motivator. Users derive joy from seeing their progress and the sense of accomplishment that comes with it. Intrinsic rewards in gamification can include feelings of competence, autonomy, and relatedness.

The Power of Extrinsic Motivation

On the other hand, extrinsic motivation involves external rewards or incentives that drive behavior. In business, extrinsic rewards can range from tangible prizes like discounts, points, or badges to intangible benefits such as recognition or status. Extrinsic motivators are often associated with short-term engagement and can be a powerful tool to kickstart user involvement.

Think about a customer loyalty program like Sephora’s Beauty Insider where customers earn points for every purchase. The promise of redeeming those points for discounts or exclusive offers serves as a strong extrinsic motivator. Users are enticed by the immediate benefits of saving money or accessing premium features.

Psychology Behind The Dual Motivation

Understanding motivation requires a deeper dive into human psychology. It’s important to recognize that individuals are not exclusively motivated by either intrinsic or extrinsic factors. In fact, humans possess a dual motivation system where both intrinsic and extrinsic motivations can coexist.

Research in psychology supports this notion. For instance, the Self-Determination Theory (SDT) posits that individuals have three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. While intrinsic motivation fulfills these needs by its very nature, extrinsic motivation can also be aligned with these needs if designed thoughtfully.

For example, receiving praise or recognition (an extrinsic reward) at work can satisfy the need for relatedness and boost intrinsic motivation. This dual motivation system suggests that businesses should not view intrinsic and extrinsic motivation as mutually exclusive but rather as complementary forces.

Another classic study that exemplifies this dual motivation system is the “Overjustification Effect.” This phenomenon occurs when individuals who initially engage in an activity for intrinsic reasons begin to lose interest when extrinsic rewards are introduced. However, when these extrinsic rewards are removed, individuals may not return to their previous level of intrinsic motivation.

Finding the Balance

The real magic of gamification in business lies in finding the right balance between intrinsic and extrinsic motivations. Striking this equilibrium can lead to sustainable and meaningful engagement. However, achieving this balance is not without its challenges.

Again considering Strava, the social fitness app that encourages users to exercise by tapping into their intrinsic motivation to achieve personal fitness goals. At the same time, it employs extrinsic motivators like leaderboards and virtual badges to promote competition and social engagement among users.

Another notable example is Starbucks’ loyalty program. While customers are intrinsically motivated by the quality of the coffee and the ambiance of Starbucks stores, the extrinsic rewards of free drinks and personalized offers through the Starbucks Rewards program provide an additional incentive for regular visits.

Enhancing User/Customer Engagement

The balance between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation serves as a catalyst for enhanced user and customer engagement. It creates a synergy that taps into the innate desire for personal satisfaction while also providing tangible benefits.

Consider the gaming industry, where the concept of gamification is most pronounced. Games are designed to be intrinsically engaging, offering challenges and experiences that players find inherently enjoyable. However, they also incorporate extrinsic rewards like achievements, leaderboards, and in-game currency to maintain player interest. This balance not only keeps players engaged but also encourages them to spend more time and money within the game. It’s this combination of intrinsic enjoyment and extrinsic rewards that sustains the gaming industry’s success.

Here are some other examples of businesses that have effectively combined both types of motivation to enhance user and customer engagement:

  • Duolingo: This language-learning app employs a combination of intrinsic motivators such as personal progress tracking and the satisfaction of learning a new language, along with extrinsic motivators like streaks and badges for consistent use.
  • LinkedIn: The professional networking platform encourages users to complete their profiles (intrinsic motivation) while providing endorsements and recommendations (extrinsic motivation) to enhance their professional image.

By aligning gamification with the specific goals of the business, these companies have successfully increased engagement, user retention, and customer satisfaction.

Practical Application

Implementing a balanced gamification strategy in business requires careful planning and execution. Here are practical steps to get started:

  • Identify Key Metrics: Determine the key performance indicators (KPIs) that align with your business goals, such as customer retention, conversion rates, or user participation.
  • Segment Your Audience: Understand the diverse motivations of your user/customer base and create tailored gamification elements for different segments.
  • Design Meaningful Rewards: Craft rewards and incentives that resonate with your audience. Ensure that extrinsic rewards have a clear connection to intrinsic values.
  • Test and Iterate: Launch your gamification strategy as a pilot and gather feedback. Use A/B testing to refine your approach over time.
  • Ethical Considerations: Be mindful of ethical concerns, ensuring that your gamification efforts are transparent, fair, and respectful of user/customer autonomy.

Gamification is a potent tool for businesses to engage their users and customers, but the key to its success lies in understanding and harnessing motivation. Balancing intrinsic and extrinsic motivations can be the secret sauce that not only drives behavior but also sustains engagement over the long term.

By acknowledging the coexistence of intrinsic and extrinsic motivations in individuals and designing gamification strategies that appeal to both, businesses can create experiences that are not only enjoyable but also rewarding. Whether you’re in education, healthcare, retail, or any other industry, finding the right balance can unlock the full potential of gamification and propel your business to new heights of success. Interested in learning more – get in touch.